How could the Elks traditional 11 o’clock toast to departed members become unpatriotic? After decades of advocacy, prohibitionists found in World War I food conservation programs an unstoppable vehicle to make prohibition of alcohol patriotic. Even before America declared war, programs saving food aimed to feed starving European refugees. Making alcohol used starch (potatoes, grain, corn) that could feed troops or hungry allies. Drinking alcohol was transformed into an unpatriotic act. Elks Lodge 616 would be square in the debate, and eventually labeled unpatriotic.
Both Hawaii’s branch of the national Anti-Saloon League and Elks Lodge 616 were founded in 1901. By World War I, the Anti-Saloon League was well organized and part of the ‘establishment.’ The press supported prohibition, even if their readers didn’t. Nippu Jiji editor Yatsutaro Soga supported prohibition and nearly lost his job. Advertiser headlines (Grain much too precious to waste in intoxicants) reminded readers liquor was now unpatriotic. “Sake not distilled wants exemption” was neutral, but “Liquor Men squealing” showed Advertiser leanings.
The Selective Service Act, May 1917, included controls on the use of liquor by men in uniform. The Advertiser bragged “Booze Taboo to Soldiers Now.” When vice did not decline, the Advertiser and the Anti-Saloon League called for stronger enforcement. 
The League found a strong partner in Army Commander Brig. Gen. J. P. Wisser. Jan 1918, he wrote Mayor Fern warning that if ‘blind pigger’ booze and bawdy houses continued, he would post Honolulu off-limits. The Advertiser predicted economic ruin if vice continued and ran cartoons showing city and state officials as hand-wringing do-nothings. Loss of business was more persuasive than moral arguments had been and a crack down followed. As restrictions tightened those who enjoyed drinking and those who profited from it looked for loopholes.
As the war continued, prohibitionists increased the pressure. Many patriots, who were not prohibitionists, felt that sacrifice was necessary both to conserve food and to show support for those making greater sacrifices on the field of battle. The debate over what “I support our troops” means is not a new one.
While prohibitionists were waging war on alcohol, what were 616 Elks doing? Like many Americans who wanted to be patriotic, yet liked a drink of something stronger than tea, Elks struggled with their choices.
After Congress declared war April 6, 1917, the city adopted a form of curfew. One restriction called for closing liquor establishments at 7pm ‘for the duration.’ Elks 616 members unanimously adopted a resolution to follow that standard.
The next step was harder to take. In Jan 1918, a proposal on the floor of the Lodge set up a fire storm of debate: “Resolved that the sale of spirituous liquors be suspended in our Club Rooms for the period of the war.” This definition would allow for wine and beer, but outlaw gin, vodka, whiskey, etc. After vigorous debate that showed no opportunity for compromise, the topic was tabled for one week. The next week’s debate brought no consensus and the topic was postponed 30 days.
Jan and Feb 1918 Lodge meetings saw attempts to create an acceptable compromise resolution. One to exclude all alcohol failed to obtain even a second. A resolution to prohibit “all intoxicating liquors except beer” seemed to be the desired compromise. It ended in a tie vote, broken by the ER’s negative vote. Just as the Territorial Legislature would struggle and fail to reach agreement, so did 616 members. Just as the community saw a connection between patriotism and alcohol, so did some 616 members. Emotions ran high with one member complaining that during the debate on this contentious issue, “the flag had been sullied.”
World War I was the first advertisers’ war. Government posters and slogans were used to form and reinforce public opinion, win support of war efforts, and boost enlistments. Slogans used by prohibition forces drove public opinion.
Despite members of the Ad Club in 616 ranks, Elks did NOT run a matching publicity campaign. During the public debate on drink, Elks 616 quietly carried on charitable acts and patriotically bought bonds. Not having ‘advertised’ their patriotic efforts, Elks were an easy target. When they opened their Advertiser Jan 24, 1918, they found themselves the most recent victim of an anonymous, self-appointed judge of patriotism. Their unpatriotic act? Resistance to universal prohibition of alcoholic beverages.
Anita Manning, Lodge Historian
Advertiser 1917 Jun 7; 1918 Feb 1, 8
Wadman, J. W. Mar 1920. The History of Prohibition in Hawaii, Friend. p 62-3
Kuykendall 1928 Hawaii in the World War
Minutes 616. Jan & Feb, 1918
Schlesinger, Jr., ed. 1983. Almanac of American History.
Star Bulletin Jun 7, 1917
 Advertiser Jan 30, 1918  Advertiser, May 13, 1917  Star Bulletin, Sep 17, 1917  Advertiser May 12 1917  Advertiser, May 26, 1917  Advertiser Sep 22, 1917, This Way Out!  Advertiser Jan 23-24, 1918. WW I’s “soldiers must be clean” approach strongly contrasts with the official wink given vice in World War II Honolulu.